205: How to Crush Negative Thoughts: Should Statements

Aug 24, 2020

Today, the Cognitive Distortion Starter Kit Continues with

Should Statements

Rhonda begins by reading a beautiful email from one of our listeners, and I give a brief shout out for my new book, Feeling Great, which can be pre-ordered on Amazon now (see below for the link). Thanks to your support, as of today (July 2) it is already the #1 best seller in the Amazon depression AND anxiety categories for impending new books!

David and Rhonda briefly summarize the history of Should Statements, starting with the Buddha 2500 years ago, and culminating in the work of Karen Horney and Albert Ellis in the 20^th century. They both emphasized that nearly all emotional suffering as well as relationship conflict results from “Shoulds.”

David and Rhonda describe the four categories of Should Statements:

• Shoulds directed against yourself cause depression, anxiety, guilt, and shame. and even lead to suicidal urges.
• Should directed against others cause anger, and can even lead to violence.
• Shoulds directed against the world cause frustration.
• Hidden Shoulds.

They also describe the three valid types of Should Statements:

• Moral Shoulds
• Legal Shoulds
• Laws of the Universe Shoulds

David and Rhonda provide vignettes illustrating the tremendous emotional damage that can result from “Shoulds” and describe a number of strategies for combating them, including:

• Positive Reframing
• the Semantic Technique
• Socratic Questioning
• the Acceptance Paradox

The final podcast in this series will focus on the two types of Blame:

• Self-Blame, which nearly always marches hand-in-hand with Self-Directed Shoulds
• Other-Blame, which nearly always marches hand-in-hand with Other-Directed Shoulds

Rhonda and David